In delving into “A Desolation Called Peace,” the sequel to Arkady Martine’s “A Memory Called Empire,” I found myself once again immersed in a universe tinged with political intrigue, cosmic mystery, and an exploration of cultural complexities. However, as a BIPOC reader, my journey through this narrative took on a nuanced tone, shaped by both the brilliance of the storytelling and the discomfort stemming from certain thematic elements.
The narrative unfolds with the Teixcalaanli Empire facing an existential threat from inscrutable alien forces. Admiral Nine Hibiscus, spearheading communication efforts, enlists the expertise of Information Ministry specialist Three Seagrass. Seagrass’s journey, now a senior Imperial official, intertwines with the reluctant involvement of her former associate, Mahit Dzmare, offering a poignant backdrop for the exploration of interstellar diplomacy and the specter of war.
Martine skillfully weaves themes carried over from the first book, contemplating the repercussions of conquest and colonialism, the nuanced definition of language, and the intricate ties individuals form with culture and institutions. The introduction of the collective consciousness theme adds layers of complexity to the narrative, challenging traditional notions of personhood.
The book’s title, echoing Tacitus’s quote about the Roman Empire, sets the stage for the exploration of the aftermath of conflict and the blurred lines between peace and desolation. As the intricate dance of diplomacy unfolds, the narrative engages both intellectually and emotionally, creating a tapestry that reflects the complexities of human experience.
However, my journey through this narrative took an unexpected turn, marked by the character of Three Seagrass. The intensification of her racist remarks and inner prejudices from the first book left me conflicted. As a person of color, it was challenging to reconcile the discomfort caused by these elements with the overall enjoyment of the narrative. The persistent racial biases within certain characters underscored the importance of critically engaging with narratives that impact marginalized communities.
“A Desolation Called Peace” continues the series’ brilliance in storytelling, expanding on established themes and introducing thought-provoking elements. The exploration of collective consciousness and the consequences of interstellar conflict adds depth to the narrative. However, the persistent racial biases within certain characters may create discomfort for some readers, underscoring the importance of critically engaging with narratives that impact marginalized communities. For those able to engage critically, the book offers a compelling continuation of an otherwise captivating series.
Leave a Reply